Hi {{first name|there}},

When someone says “the ROI is excellent,” which return metric are they referring to?

Five different measures of return are commonly cited in capital conversations. Each one answers a different question. Using the wrong one for the decision at hand is how companies allocate capital they later regret — and how boards and lenders lose confidence in management’s financial judgment.

Most executives know these acronyms. Very few can explain when to use each one, how to calculate it correctly, or how to use it properly.

Here’s what we’re covering in this issue:

After successfully running The CEO Financial Intelligence 6-week program for several cohorts in 2025, I am finally launching the CEO Financial Intelligence Academy — a structured, three-tier annual membership that takes CEOs from financial literacy to institutional-grade financial intelligence.

If you’re running a $5M–$200M+ company and your investment decisions still feel more like gut feel than discipline — if your strategy and your cash flow aren’t in the same conversation — if your P&L is the only statement your leadership team truly watches — this is what I built for you.

The CEO Financial Intelligence Academy is a complete financial operating system — curriculum, coaching, and community — built on your real company numbers.

Three Academy Programs — one integrated system:

BUILD — The 6-week Live Curriculum + Coaching on your academy-built CEO Dashboard + Community access

LEAD — Everything in BUILD + monthly CEO Financial Dashboard update + monthly group dashboard reviews.

COMMAND — Everything in LEAD + automated real time institutional-grade financial intelligence infrastructure. 18+ Custom Built Power BI dashboards, 60-month rolling forecasts, full suite of analytics and CEO/CFO decision ready intelligence.

Learn more here academy.oanalabes.com and stay tuned for when we officially open enrolment.

ChatGPT is insanely powerful.

But most people waste 90% of its potential by using it like Google.

These 1,000+ proven ChatGPT prompts fix that and help you work 10X faster.

Sign up for Superhuman AI and get:

Claim your free prompts

Most executives do not need more return metrics.

They need to know which one to use, when to use it, and what decision it actually helps them make.

ROI, ROIC, ROE, ROCE, and ROA are not interchangeable. Each one answers a different question. And if you rely on the wrong one, you can misread performance, approve weak investments, or confuse growth with value creation.

Formula:
(Net benefit from the investment ÷ cost of the investment) × 100

What it helps you answer: Did this specific investment pay off?

Why it matters: ROI is the broadest and simplest return metric. It is useful when you are evaluating a discrete initiative where the cost and benefit can be isolated reasonably well.

This could be a marketing campaign, a software implementation, a pricing initiative, a plant upgrade, or a hiring decision. In those cases, ROI gives executives a quick way to compare alternatives and screen decisions before committing capital.

What makes it useful: It is simple, fast, and easy to communicate.

What it misses: ROI does not account for time, risk, financing mix, or cash flow timing.

A 20% ROI earned in 6 months is not the same as a 20% ROI earned over 4 years. Two projects can also show the same ROI while having very different risk profiles and very different cash consequences.

Best use: Use ROI as a first-pass decision tool for specific initiatives.

Do not use it as: A full test of long-term value creation.

Formula: Net operating profit after tax ÷ average invested capital

What it helps you answer: Is the business generating enough operating return on the capital required to run it?

Why it matters: ROIC is one of the most important metrics an executive can understand because it goes far beyond “did profit increase?”

It tells you whether the business is using capital efficiently enough to actually create value.

A company can grow revenue, EBITDA, and net income and still become economically weaker if it needs too much capital to support that growth.

More receivables, more inventory, more equipment, more working capital, and more capital tied up for every dollar of incremental return can all make growth look stronger than it really is.

That is where ROIC becomes critical.

It shows whether operating profit is strong enough relative to the capital tied up in the business.

What makes it useful: ROIC connects operating performance, capital allocation, growth quality, and enterprise value.

The key test: ROIC only becomes truly meaningful when compared to WACC.

If ROIC is above WACC, the business is creating value. If ROIC is below WACC, the business may still be growing, but that growth is destroying value rather than building it.

Best use: Use ROIC when evaluating overall capital efficiency, growth quality, acquisitions, expansion decisions, and capital allocation discipline.

Do not use it as: A standalone answer without understanding what is driving the numerator and denominator.

Formula: Net income ÷ average shareholders’ equity

What it helps you answer: How much return did the company generate on the equity invested by shareholders?

Why it matters: ROE measures performance from the equity holder’s perspective. It tells you how effectively the company converted its equity base into accounting profit.

That is why boards, investors, and owners often look at it closely.

What makes it useful: It gives a direct view of shareholder return on book equity.

What it misses: ROE can be heavily influenced by leverage.

A company with high debt, low equity, aggressive buybacks, or a thin capital base can show a very strong ROE even if the underlying business is not especially strong.

That is the trap.

A high ROE can reflect genuine operating strength, or it can reflect financial structure doing the work.

Best use: Use ROE when the discussion is specifically about shareholder returns, ownership performance, or equity efficiency.

Do not use it as: Your main test of business quality or value creation.

Formula: EBIT ÷ average capital employed

Capital employed is usually: Total assets minus current liabilities

What it helps you answer: How effectively is the business generating operating earnings from the capital committed to it?

Why it matters: ROCE is often used in capital-intensive businesses where asset deployment has a major influence on performance.

It is especially useful in sectors like manufacturing, industrials, infrastructure, and utilities.

For executives, ROCE helps spotlight whether the capital base is actually productive.

What makes it useful: It gives a practical view of operating return relative to the capital committed to the business.

What it misses: ROCE is less precise than ROIC when the real question is value creation.

That is because it usually uses EBIT, not after-tax operating profit. It is also less precise because the definition of capital employed can vary, which means comparisons are not always clean.

Best use: Use ROCE when you want to evaluate capital productivity, operational performance in asset-heavy businesses, or internal benchmarking.

Do not use it as: A substitute for ROIC when the real question is whether the company is earning above its cost of capital.

Formula: Net income ÷ average total assets

What it helps you answer: How much profit is the company generating from its asset base?

Why it matters: ROA is a broad asset-efficiency metric. It helps executives understand how productively the balance sheet is being used to generate profit.

It can be useful when comparing businesses where asset intensity matters, or when tracking whether a company is becoming more or less efficient over time.

What makes it useful: It gives a high-level read on how well assets are being turned into profit.

What it misses: Because ROA usually uses net income, it can be influenced by financing structure, tax position, accounting policies, asset age, and write-downs.

So ROA is useful, but it is not a clean operating-return measure.

Best use: Use ROA for broad efficiency analysis, balance sheet productivity, and trend tracking over time.

Do not use it as: A precise measure of value creation or capital allocation quality.

Use ROI when you want a quick read on a specific initiative.

Use ROIC when you want to know whether the business is creating value from the capital it uses.

Use ROE when the question is about returns to shareholders.

Use ROCE when you want to assess capital productivity in asset-heavy businesses.

Use ROA when you want a broad view of asset efficiency.

A company can report a strong ROI on a project, a healthy ROE for shareholders, and a decent-looking ROA, and still have a weak ROIC that tells you the business is not creating enough value on the capital it keeps deploying.

That is why these metrics matter. Not because executives need more formulas. Because executives need to know which return metric matches which decision.

The most expensive return metric mistake isn’t using the wrong formula. It’s approving capital decisions without comparing returns to the cost of capital.

A hurdle rate is the minimum acceptable return for a capital deployment. It reflects the weighted average cost of capital — what it actually costs the company to fund itself through debt and equity. Any investment that returns less than the WACC is, by definition, destroying value even if it looks profitable in absolute terms.

Most companies don’t have an explicit hurdle rate. Investments get approved because they “look positive,” or because the initiative has strong advocates, or because a department “has room in the budget.” None of those criteria answer the only question that matters: does this return exceed the cost of capital required to fund it?

Revenue is not a return metric. Neither is EBITDA growth. Neither is “strategic fit.” These are inputs to a return calculation, not outputs. Companies that approve major capital deployments based on revenue projections alone are not doing capital allocation. They are doing revenue planning — which is a different, less disciplined activity.

For major capital decisions, use ROIC compared to WACC. For project-specific or marketing analysis, use IRR (Internal Rate of Return) and NPV alongside ROI. For equity holder reporting, include ROE in context. For operational efficiency analysis, use ROCE or ROA as sector-appropriate benchmarks.

The question that should precede every major capital decision is not “what is the ROI?” It is: “What is the ROIC on this deployment relative to our cost of capital, and what has to be true for it to remain above threshold under realistic downside conditions?”

That question changes the quality of every capital decision that follows it.

You’ll get the decision making frameworks alongside a state-of-the-art CEO Dashboard customized to your company to make sure the answers to your biggest scaling questions are always available - all that inside an executive community that shares your drive and commitment.

You’ll finally have the operating system a CEO needs to lead capital conversations with authority: cash flow strategy, risk visibility, and capital allocation logic that holds up in real conversations — with boards, lenders, investors, and your own leadership team.

BUILD · LEAD · COMMAND — three programs, one integrated system.

→ Watch the free 60-minute CEO Masterclass and take the free CEO Blind- Spot Diagnostic^TM to get started.

See you next week.

Oana